Credit:
Reviewed / Tim Renzi
Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed's editors. Purchases made through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission. Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.
Credit:
Reviewed / Tim Renzi
Reviewed's mission is to help you buy the best stuff and get the most out of what you already own. Our team of product experts thoroughly vet every product we recommend to help you cut through the clutter and find what you need.
Learn more about our product testing
This cooler provides superb insulation and maintained a brisk temperature for over three days. Read More
The Rtic Ultra Light Cooler lives up to its name and is lightweight so you can haul it to the beach or a campsite. Read More
This feature-rich cooler comes with everything you need—including a padded seat—for a day outdoors. Read More
We found the Pelican Elite to be bulky to move around, however, it offers plenty of features and is good at retaining temperatures Read More
While the Orca 40-quart cooler has easy-to-carry handles and secure t-grip locks, it's slow to reach a brisk temperature for proper chilling. Read More
When you’re unwinding outdoors, the best cooler makes all the difference. From keeping your catch fresh on a deep sea fishing trip to keeping your cold ones chilly at the beach, coolers are essential. You have a limited amount of leisure time—don’t let a bad cooler ruin it.
After weeks of testing the best coolers available, the Yeti Tundra 45 (available at Yeti) came out on top for its ability to hold brisk temperatures for days at a time and its secure locks to prevent leakage.
For a great option at a lower price, the Rtic Ultra Light Hard Cooler (available at Amazon) offers incredible value.
For the best rolling cooler decked out with fun features like a padded seat and built-in drink tap, check out the BruMate BruTank (available at BruMate).
There are plenty of other winners among the coolers we tested, for all priorities and price points.
The Yeti Tundra 45 showed us why Yeti is a leader in the field.
This lightweight cooler from Rtic is our favorite affordable option.
The Brumate BruTank cooler has all the bells and whistles.
Good temperature retention
Feature filled
Skid-resistant bottom
Bulky
High price point
Easy to carry
Extra storage
Subpar insulation
Affordable
Easy to move
Features cupholders
Strong plastic scent
Weaker insulation
Retro design
Good insulation
Hard to carry
Difficult to lock
Holds temperature overnight
Doesn't require ice
Requires charging
Drains car battery
Hi, Jon Chan, Beckett Dubay, and Michael Elderbee here! We’re the testing team at Reviewed, which means we design and implement the experiments involved in this article. For the best coolers, we are most concerned about performance, portability, and price.
We tested these coolers for insulation, portability, and durability.
When searching for the best cooler or ice chest to test, we researched the most popular units on the market. We also wanted to include a variety of coolers, from hard to soft, portable to heavy-duty. We also took care to find widely available coolers.
We tested how long each cooler could maintain a temperature by filling each cooler, regardless of size, halfway up with ice. Next, we put the ice coolers into our humidity-controlled lab space to ensure a consistent ambient temperature of 72°F and 50% relative humidity.
To track the temperature of each cooler, we placed two temperature sensors inside to measure when the internal conditions reached over 40°F—the point at which meat becomes unsafe to eat.
We placed one sensor at the bottom of the cooler, wrapped inside a cube of methylcellulose buried in ice. We placed the other sensor on top of the ice and removed it daily to get readings and simulate normal use. The test ended when a cooler visibly contained no ice.
The next tests involved the portability, build quality, and aesthetics of each ice cooler. The portability test was pretty straightforward: Fill the cooler with water and walk around with it. We went up inclines, took sharp turns, and trotted around the lab.
Exhausted and out of breath, we then tested whether they were leakproof by tipping each cooler to determine whether the water would come out. Then, we emptied each model of water to look into the design and features. Finally, we filled each cooler with soda cans to see how many cans they could hold, compared to their stated capacity.
Make sure to add the right amount of ice to your cooler to keep everything chilly.
You should use a 2-to-1 ratio of ice to items being cooled. For example, if you were cooling a gallon jug of milk, you’d need two gallons of ice to keep it cool. However, the more ice the better the food preservation.
• Pre-cool your cooler: If you’re storing your cooler in a hot garage, bring it inside so it can get up to room temperature. That way, you’re not wasting energy cooling down a hot plastic box.
• Avoid using ice that's already melting: A bag of ice that's dripping water is already too warm to keep a cooler at the correct temperature.
• Don't drain out the excess water: Cold water helps insulate any ice you add later.
Dry ice is okay for use in most coolers. It’s way colder than regular ice and excels at keeping ice cream and meat frozen. When it evaporates, it leaves no puddles to clean up.
However, there are disadvantages. Dry ice melts at an alarming rate, about 5-10 pounds every hour, depending on how often you open the cooler. It’s also somewhat dangerous to store indoors, as it is releases carbon dioxide.
It all comes down to how long and how far you’re going.
For day trips, a portable soft cooler or a backpack cooler is perfect. (Just keep in mind that backpack coolers work better with ice packs than loose cubes. Once that ice melts, the sloshing will make the backpack more unstable.)
If you’re heading into the backcountry, you'll want a cooler that is more robust. The best coolers that keep hot air out have T-handles and are difficult to open because of the tight seal. You want a well-insulated unit that keeps the scent of your supplies away from bears and other predators.
When packing a cooler to preserve food for more than a day, use a combination of chunks and chips of ice. Chips help with immediate cooling and chunks are for the long haul. Also, store the cooler in the shade, away from direct sunlight.
Jonathan Chan currently serves as the Lab Manager at Reviewed. If you clean with it, it's likely that Jon oversees its testing. Since joining the Reviewed in 2012, Jon has helped launch the company's efforts in reviewing laptops, vacuums, and outdoor gear. He thinks he's a pretty big deal. In the pursuit of data, he's plunged his hands into freezing cold water, consented to be literally dragged through the mud, and watched paint dry. Jon demands you have a nice day.
Beckett Dubay
Product Test Technician
Beckett Dubay is a product tester at Reviewed, regularly using science-based protocol to test refrigerators, dishwashers, and laundry large appliances, and photographing the process in the lab from start to finish.
Before Reviewed, working as a lighting designer for several years has left him with strong opinions about overhead lighting.
Michael Elderbee
Product Test Technician
Born in Seoul and raised in New England, Michael is currently a Product Test Technician at Reviewed and strives to make sure you get the most bang for your buck.
In the Reviewed lab, Michael regularly tests refrigerators, dishwashers, and laundry large appliances, as well as all types of science-based activities.
His 5 years as a behavioral technician has given him a strong appreciation for data collection and research. Michael has a variety of different passions outside of testing appliances including volleyball, snowboarding, and video games. You can also find him nerding out about EDC gear, custom keyboards, and Warhammer 40k.
Our team is here for one purpose: to help you buy the best stuff and love what you own. Our writers, editors, and lab technicians obsess over the products we cover to make sure you're confident and satisfied. Have a different opinion about something we recommend? Email us and we'll compare notes.
Shoot us an email
